������
��������������������
�
������������������
�
������������������
�
������������������
�
������������������
�
������������������
�
������������������
������������������� Boston Sustain Arguments Against Aid to Israel
������� ������������I. Israeli violations of the objectives of the US Foreign Aid
������������������� Program:
������������������� In relation to the Middle East, the US aid program supports
������������������� peace, stability, democratization, and ending refugee
������������������� situations.
������������������� The following details on all four objectives show Israeli
������������������� disregard for these objectives.
������������������� 1. Stability:
��������������������� A.The occupation of Palestinian and Syrian territories has destabilized the
������������������������ region for over 35 years. By US and International laws, the occupation is
������������������������ illegal.
��������������������� B.The US has sided with UN and all other international organizations
������������������������ condemning the occupation of the West Bank, Gaza, East Jerusalem, and
������������������������ the Golan Heights as illegal and in violation of international laws, and has
������������������������ demanded withdrawal from all occupied territories.
��������������������� C.The US does not recognize Israel's sovereignty over East Jerusalem, or all
������������������������ alterations to the status of the city introduced by Israel since 1967.
��������������������� D.The US considers all settlements in the occupied territories illegal and has
������������������������ demanded its removal.
������������������� 2. Peace:
������������������� Right wing partners in the Sharon coalition government are
������������������� opposed to the peace process with the Palestinians. The
������������������� Sharon government's practices of land confiscation, house
������������������� demolition, and building more settlements show that peace
������������������� is not a priority.
����� ��������������3. Democratization:
��������������������� A.Israel is a democracy, but for Jews only. Especially, Israeli Arabs do not
������������������������ enjoy the legal status or the civil liberties Jews enjoy. Discrimination against
�������������� ����������Arabs is a policy followed by successive Israeli governments.
��������������������� B.The existing of troubling racist practices in the occupied territories, such land
������������������������ confiscation, house demolishing, segregation of Arab villages by networks of
������������������������ settlements and over‑passes available to Jews only. Such practices are
������������������������ documented by responsible International bodies and Israeli human rights
������������������������ organizations.
������������������� 4. Ending Refugee Situations:
������������������� Israel has aggravated the problem of refugees. House
������������������� demolition, confiscation of Palestinian land, rejection of the
������������������� right of return for generations of Palestinians made
������������������� refugees since 1948.
������������������� [Back to summary]
������������������� II. Israeli violations of the conditions of the US Foreign Aid
������������������� Program:
������������������� Several of the conditions for granting aid are not met by
������������������� Israel. The US Aid program states that aid is to be given if
������������������� Israel takes action or meets conditions in keeping with US
������������������� policies:
�������������������� �1.The US can withhold aid if Israel continues building settlements in Arab
������������������������ occupied territories. The settlements have nearly doubled since the Oslo
������������������������ accords, but, ironically, aid to Israel has increased.
��������������������� 2.Economic conditions for aid have not been met by Israel. Israel has not
������������������������ made necessary economic reforms, such as: privatization of government
������������������������ owned enterprises; cutting subsidies for housing in the occupied territories;
������������������������ and implementing austerity measures.
��������������������� 3.Part of the Aid funds is loans that should be repaid. Military aid to Israel is
������������������������ labeled "Loans," but Israel usually does not repay. Repayments are
������������������������ "waived." Israel prefers loans she does not repay over "grants" funds which
������������������������ come with conditions: US military overseeing the grants program. Israel, in
������������ ������������other words, gets grants without US supervision.
������������������� [Back to summary]
������������������� III. Israeli misuse of Aid funds:
������������������� The US has investigated several Israeli instances of misuse
������������������ �of aid funds without taking action against Israel:
��������������������� 1.Israel has used Aid money in the occupied territories, especially in building
������������������������ settlements.
��������������������� 2.Israel has used weapons for non‑defensive purposes, and the conditions for
������������������������ military aid state. US government has investigated Israeli violations in 1978,
������������������������ 1979, 1981, 1982, and most recently 2001, when helicopter gunships were
���������������� ��������used in assassinating Palestinian leaders, and when f‑16 fighters were used in
������������������������ bombing Palestinian civilian buildings.
��������������������� 3.Israel has transferred technology without US approval. Israel has been
������� �����������������transferring technology for decades, giving weapons and technology to
������������������������ China, South Africa, Chile, Ethiopia, and other countries.
������������������� [Back to summary]
������������������� IV. Israel's engagement in espionage affairs in the US:
������������������� In violation of aid conditions, Israel has engaged in
������������������� espionage in the US that targets military and civilian
������������������� technology. The two cases of Richard Smyth (1985) and
������������������� Jonathan Pollard (1985) both indicted on charges of selling
������������������� prohibited technology (Smyth) or classified information
������������������� (Pollard).
������������������� Other cases have confirmed Israel has been spying on the
������������������� US consistently with relative impunity. In 1986, an Illinois
������������������� company complained of Israeli attempts to steal data on
������������������� aerial reconnaissance cameras, and an engineer at a
��������������� ����military testing facility in Michigan admitted he gave
������������������� classified material to Israel in the period of 1987‑1997.
������������������� [Back to summary]
UN Resolutions Against Israel,
���������� 1955‑1992
���������� (Findley's Deliberate Deceptions, 1998 pages 188 ‑ 192)
���������� 1. Resolution 106: "... 'condemns' Israel for Gaza raid"
���������� 2. Resolution 111: "...'condemns' Israel for raid on Syria that killed
���������� fifty‑six people"
���������� 3. Resolution 127: "...'recommends' Israel suspend its 'no‑man's
���������� zone' in Jerusalem"
���������� 4. Resolution 162: "...'urges' Israel to comply with UN decisions"
���������� 5. Resolution 171: "...determines flagrant violations' by Israel in its
���������� attack on Syria"
���������� 6. Resolution 228: "...'censures' Israel for its attack on Samu in the
���������� West Bank, then under Jordanian control"
���������� 7. Resolution 237: "...'urges' Israel to allow return of new 1967
���������� Palestinian refugees"
���������� 8. Resolution 248: "... 'condemns' Israel for its massive attack on
���������� Karameh in Jordan"
���������� 9. Resolution 250: "... 'calls' on Israel to refrain from holding
���������� military parade in Jerusalem"
���������� 10. Resolution 251: "... 'deeply deplores' Israeli military parade in
���������� Jerusalem in defiance of Resolution 250"
���������� 11. Resolution 252: "...'declares invalid' Israel's acts to unify
���������� Jerusalem as Jewish capital"
���������� 12. Resolution 256: "... 'condemns' Israeli raids on Jordan as
���������� 'flagrant
���������� violation""
���������� 13. Resolution 259: "...'deplores' Israel's refusal to accept UN
���������� mission to probe occupation"
���������� 14. Resolution 262: "...'condemns' Israel for attack on Beirut airport"
���������� 15. Resolution 265: "... 'condemns' Israel for air attacks for Salt in
���������� Jordan"
���������� 16. Resolution 267: "...'censures' Israel for administrative acts to
���������� change the status of Jerusalem"
���������� 17. Resolution 270: "...'condemns' Israel for air attacks on villages in
���������� southern Lebanon"
���������� 18. Resolution 271: "...'condemns' Israel's failure to obey UN
���������� resolutions on Jerusalem"
�������� ��19. Resolution 279: "...'demands' withdrawal of Israeli forces from
���������� Lebanon"
���������� 20. Resolution 280: "....'condemns' Israeli's attacks against Lebanon"
���������� 21. Resolution 285: "...'demands' immediate Israeli withdrawal form
���������� Lebanon"
���������� 22. Resolution 298: "...'deplores' Israel's changing of the status of
���������� Jerusalem"
���������� 23. Resolution 313: "...'demands' that Israel stop attacks against
���������� Lebanon"
���������� 24. Resolution 316: "...'condemns' Israel for repeated attacks on
���������� Lebanon"
���������� 25. Resolution 317: "...'deplores' Israel's refusal to release Arabs
���������� abducted in Lebanon"
���������� 26. Resolution 332: "...'condemns' Israel's repeated attacks against
���������� Lebanon"
���������� 27. Resolution 337: "...'condemns' Israel for violating Lebanon's
���������� sovereignty"
���������� 28. Resolution 347: "...'condemns' Israeli attacks on Lebanon"
���������� 29. Resolution 425: "...'calls' on Israel to withdraw its forces from
���������� Lebanon"
���������� 30. Resolution 427: "...'calls' on Israel to complete its withdrawal
���������� from Lebanon'
���������� 31. Resolution 444: "...'deplores' Israel's lack of cooperation with
���������� UN peacekeeping forces"
���������� 32. Resolution 446: "...'determines' that Israeli settlements are a
���������� 'serious obstruction' to peace and calls on Israel to abide by the
���������� Fourth Geneva Convention"
���������� 33. Resolution 450: "...'calls' on Israel to stop attacking Lebanon"
���������� 34. Resolution 452: "...'calls' on Israel to cease building settlements
���������� in occupied territories"
���������� 35. Resolution 465: "...'deplores' Israel's settlements and asks all
���������� member states not to assist Israel's settlements program"
���������� 36. Resolution 467: "...'strongly deplores' Israel's military
���������� intervention in Lebanon"
���������� 37. Resolution 468: "...'calls' on Israel to rescind illegal expulsions
��� �������of two Palestinian mayors and a judge and to facilitate their return"
���������� 38. Resolution 469: "...'strongly deplores' Israel's failure to observe
���������� the council's order not to deport Palestinians"
���������� 39. Resolution 471: "... 'expresses deep concern' at Israel's failure to
���������� abide by the Fourth Geneva Convention"
���������� 40. Resolution 476: "... 'reiterates' that Israel's claims to Jerusalem
���������� are 'null and void'"
���������� 41. Resolution 478: "...'censures (Israel) in the strongest terms' for
���������� its claim to Jerusalem in its 'Basic Law'"
���������� 42. Resolution 484: "...'declares it imperative' that Israel re‑admit
���������� two deported Palestinian mayors"
���������� 43. Resolution 487: "...'strongly condemns' Israel for its attack on
���������� Iraq's nuclear facility"
���������� 44. Resolution 497: "...'decides' that Israel's annexation of Syria's
���������� Golan Heights is 'null and void' and demands that Israel rescind its
��� �������decision forthwith"
���������� 45. Resolution 498: "...'calls' on Israel to withdraw from Lebanon"
���������� 46. Resolution 501: "...'calls' on Israel to stop attacks against
���������� Lebanon and withdraw its troops"
���������� 47. Resolution 509: "...'demands' that Israel withdraw its forces
���������� forthwith and unconditionally from Lebanon"
���������� 48. Resolution 515: "...'demands' that Israel lift its siege of Beirut
���������� and allow food supplies to be brought in"
���������� 49. Resolution 517: "...'censures' Israel for failing to obey UN
���������� resolutions and demands that Israel withdraw its forces from
���������� Lebanon"
���������� 50. Resolution 518: "...'demands' that Israel cooperate fully with UN
���������� forces in Lebanon"
���������� 51. Resolution 520: "...'condemns' Israel's attack into West Beirut"
���������� 52. Resolution 573: "...'condemns' Israel 'vigorously' for bombing
���������� Tunisia in attack on PLO headquarters
���������� 53. Resolution 587: "...'takes note' of previous calls on Israel to
���������� withdraw its forces from Lebanon and urges all parties to withdraw"
���������� 54. Resolution 592: "...'strongly deplores' the killing of Palestinian
���������� students at Bir Zeit University by Israeli troops"
���������� 55. Resolution 605: "...'strongly deplores' Israel's policies and
���������� practices denying the human rights of Palestinians
���������� 56. Resolution 607: "...'calls' on Israel not to deport Palestinians and
�������� ��strongly requests it to abide by the Fourth Geneva Convention
���������� 57. Resolution 608: "...'deeply regrets' that Israel has defied the
���������� United Nations and deported Palestinian civilians"
���������� 58. Resolution 636: "...'deeply regrets' Israeli deportation of
���������� Palestinian civilians
���������� 59. Resolution 641: "...'deplores' Israel's continuing deportation of
���������� Palestinians
���������� 60. Resolution 672: "...'condemns' Israel for violence against
���������� Palestinians at the Haram al‑Sharif/Temple Mount
���������� 61. Resolution 673: "...'deplores' Israel's refusal to cooperate with
���������� the United Nations
���������� 62. Resolution 681: "...'deplores' Israel's resumption of the
���������� deportation of Palestinians
���������� 63. Resolution 694: "...'deplores' Israel's deportation of Palestinians
���������� and calls on it to ensure their safe and immediate return
���������� 64. Resolution 726: "...'strongly condemns' Israel's deportation of
��� �������Palestinians
���������� 65. Resolution 799: "...'strongly condemns' Israel's deportation of
���������� 413 Palestinians and calls for their immediate return.
���������� The following are the resolutions vetoed by the United States during
������� ���the period of September, 1972, to May, 1990 to protect Israel from
���������� council criticism:
���������� 1. Condemned Israel's attack against Southern against
���������� southern Lebanon and Syria..."
���������� 2. ....affirmed the rights of the Palestinian people to
���������� self‑determination, statehood and equal protections..."
���������� 3. ...condemned Israel's air strikes and attacks in southern Lebanon
���������� and its murder of innocent civilians..."
���������� 4. ....called for self‑determination of Palestinian people..."
���������� 5. ....deplored Israel's altering of the status of Jerusalem, which is
���������� recognized as an international city by most world nations and the
���������� United Nations..."
���������� 6. ....affirmed the inalienable rights of the Palestinian people..."
���������� 7. ....endorsed self‑determination for the Palestinian people..."
���������� 8. ....demanded Israel's withdrawal from the Golan Heights..."
���������� 9. ....condemned Israel's mistreatment of Palestinians in the occupied
���������� West Bank and Gaza Strip and its refusal to abide by the Geneva
���������� convention protocols of civilized nations..."
���������� 10. ....condemned an Israeli soldier who shot eleven Moslem
���������� worshippers >at the Haram al‑Sharif/Temple Mount near Al‑Aqsa
���������� Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem..."
���������� 11. ....urged sanctions against Israel if it did not withdraw from its
���������� invasion of Lebanon..."
���������� 12. ....urged sanctions against Israel if it did not withdraw from its
���������� invasion of Beirut..."
���������� 14. ....urged cutoff of economic aid to Israel if it refused to withdraw
���������� from its occupation of Lebanon..."
���������� 15. ....condemned continued Israeli settlements in occupied
���������� territories
���������� in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, denouncing them as an obstacle to
���������� peace..."
���������� 16. ....deplores Israel's brutal massacre of Arabs in Lebanon and
���������� urges its withdrawal..."
���������� 17. ....condemned Israeli brutality in southern Lebanon and
���������� denounced the Israeli 'Iron Fist' policy of repression...."
���������� 18. ....denounced Israel's violation of human rights in the occupied
��������� �territories..."
���������� 19. ....deplored Israel's violence in southern Lebanon..."
���������� 20. ....deplored Israel's activities in occupied Arab East Jerusalem
���������� that threatened the sanctity of Muslim holy sites..."
���������� 21. ....condemned Israel's hijacking of a Libyan passenger
���������� airplane..."
���������� 22. ....deplored Israel's attacks against Lebanon and its measures
���������� and practices against the civilian population of Lebanon..."
���������� 23. ....called on Israel to abandon its policies against the Palestinian
���������� intifada that violated the rights of occupied Palestinians, to abide by
���������� the Fourth Geneva Conventions, and to formalize a leading role for
���������� the United Nations in future peace negotiations..."
���������� 24. ....urged Israel to accept back deported Palestinians,
���������� condemned
���������� Israel's shooting of civilians, called on Israel to uphold the Fourth
���������� Geneva Convention, and called for a peace settlement under UN
���������� auspices..."
���������� 25. ....condemned Israel's... incursion into Lebanon..."
���������� 26. ....deplored Israel's... commando raids on Lebanon..."
���������� 27. ....deplored Israel's repression of the Palestinian intifada and
���������� called on Israel to respect the human rights of the Palestinians..."
���������� 28. ....deplored Israel's violation of the human rights of the
���������� Palestinians..."
���������� 29. ....demanded that Israel return property confiscated from
���������� Palestinians during a tax protest and allow a fact‑finding mission to
���������� observe Israel's crackdown on the Palestinian intifada..."
���������� 30. ...called for a fact‑finding mission on abuses against Palestinians
���������� in Israeli‑occupied lands..."
���������� ‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑
���������� Source: Paul Findley, Deliberate Deceptions: Facing the Facts About
���������� the US/Israeli Relationship (Chicago: Lawrence Hill, 1993).
����������������������������� ���������������������������������List of US
�������������������������������������������������������������� Resolutions against
Subject:
������� Israeli violations of UN resolutions
�� Date:
������� Tue, 11 Feb 2003 15:15:27 ‑0800
�� From:
������� Meggie <[email protected]>
���� To:
������� Willie Martin <[email protected]>
���������������������������������
����������������� Jews Against the Occupation
������������������������ UN Resolutions
���
�� Palestinian Refugees have the right to return to their homes in Israel.
�� General Assembly Resolution 194, Dec. 11, 1948
�����
�� "Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with
�� their neighbors should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that
�� compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for
�� loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity,
�� should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible."
���
�� Israel's occupation of Palestine is Illegal.
�� Security Council Resolution 242, Nov. 22, 1967
�����
�� Calls for the withdrawal of Israeli forces from territories occupied in the war that year
�� and "the acknowledgment of the sovereignty, territorial integrity and political
�� independence of every state in the area and their right to live in peace within secure
�� and recognized boundaries free from threats or acts of force."
���
�� Israel's settlements in Palestine are Illegal.
�� Security Council Resolution 446, March 22, 1979
������
�� "Determines that the policy and practices of Israel in establishing settlements in the
�� Palestinian and other Arab territories occupied since 1967 have no legal validity and
�� constitute a serious obstruction to achieving a comprehensive, just and lasting peace
�� in the Middle East."
���
�� Palestinian have the right to Self‑Determination.
�� General Assembly Resolution 3236, November 22, 1974
�����
�� Affirms "the inalienable rights of the Palestinian people in Palestine...to
�� self‑determination without external interference" and "to national independence and
�� sovereignty."
���
�� Reaffirmation of a Palestinian State
�� Security Council Resolution 1397, March 12, 2002
�����
� �Affirms "a vision of a region where two states, Israel and Palestine, live side by side
�� within secure and recognized borders."
���
�� Also see:
����
�� UN General Assembly Resolution 181 ‑ the 1947 Partition plan of Palestine and the
�� creation of Israel.
�����
�� International Humanitarian Law: the Geneva Conventions ‑ 150 years of international
�� designated protection of civilians during wartime and Israel's explicit violations.
������
�� History of the Palestinian Problem ‑ from the Division for Palestinian Rights, United
�� Nations
�����
�� Countless More UN Resolutions on Israel ‑ 1955‑1992
���
���
���
�� More UN Resolutions on Israel, 1955‑1992
���
�� Resolution 106: condemns Israel for Gaza raid.
�� Resolution 111: condemns Israel for raid on Syria that killed fifty‑six people.
�� Resolution 127: recommends Israel suspend its no‑man's zone' in Jerusalem.
�� Resolution 162: urges Israel to comply with UN decisions.
�� Resolution 171: determines flagrant violations by Israel in its attack on Syria.
�� Resolution 228: censures Israel for its attack on Samu in the West Bank, then under
�� Jordanian control.
�� Resolution 237: urges Israel to allow return of new 1967 Palestinian refugees.
�� Resolution 248: condemns Israel for its massive attack on Karameh in Jordan.
�� Resolution 250: calls on Israel to refrain from holding military parade in Jerusalem.
�� Resolution 251: deeply deplores Israeli military parade in Jerusalem in defiance of
�� Resolution 250.
�� Resolution 252: declares invalid Israel's acts to unify Jerusalem as Jewish capital.
�� Resolution 256: condemns Israeli raids on Jordan as flagrant violation.
�� Resolution 259: deplores Israel's refusal to accept UN mission to probe occupation.
�� Resolution 262: condemns Israel for attack on Beirut airport.
�� Resolution 265: condemns Israel for air attacks for Salt in Jordan.
�� Resolution 267: censures Israel for administrative acts to change the status of
�� Jerusalem.
�� Resolution 270: condemns Israel for air attacks on villages in southern Lebanon.
�� Resolution 271: condemns Israel's failure to obey UN resolutions on Jerusalem.
�� Resolution 279: demands withdrawal of Israeli forces from Lebanon.
�� Resolution 280: condemns Israeli's attacks against Lebanon.
�� Resolution 285: demands immediate Israeli withdrawal from Lebanon.
�� Resolution 298: deplores Israel's changing of the status of Jerusalem.
�� Resolution 313: demands that Israel stop attacks against Lebanon.
�� Resolution 316: condemns Israel for repeated attacks on Lebanon.
�� Resolution 317: deplores Israel's refusal to release.
�� Resolution 332: condemns Israel's repeated attacks against Lebanon.
�� Resolution 337: condemns Israel for violating Lebanon's sovereignty.
�� Resolution 347: condemns Israeli attacks on Lebanon.
�� Resolution 425: calls on Israel to withdraw its forces from Lebanon.
�� Resolution 427: calls on Israel to complete its withdrawal from Lebanon.
�� Resolution 444: deplores Israel's lack of cooperation with UN peacekeeping forces.
�� Resolution 446: determines that Israeli settlements are a serious obstruction to peace
�� and calls on Israel to abide by the Fourth Geneva Convention
�� Resolution 450: calls on Israel to stop attacking Lebanon.
�� Resolution 452: calls on Israel to cease building settlements in occupied territories.
�� Resolution 465: deplores Israel's settlements and asks all member states not to
�� assist its settlements program.
�� Resolution 467: strongly deplores Israel's military intervention in Lebanon.
�� Resolution 468: calls on Israel to rescind illegal expulsions of two Palestinian mayors
�� and a judge and to facilitate their return.
�� Resolution 469: strongly deplores Israel's failure to observe the council's order not to
�� deport Palestinians.
�� Resolution 471: expresses deep concern at Israel's failure to abide by the Fourth
�� Geneva Convention.
�� Resolution 476: reiterates that Israel's claim to Jerusalem are null and void.
�� Resolution 478: censures (Israel) in the strongest terms for its claim to Jerusalem in
�� its Basic Law.
�� Resolution 484: declares it imperative that Israel re‑admit two deported Palestinian
�� mayors.
�� Resolution 487: strongly condemns Israel for its attack on Iraq's nuclear facility.
�� Resolution 497: decides that Israel's annexation of Syria's Golan Heights
�� is null and void and demands that Israel rescinds its decision forthwith.
�� Resolution 498: calls on Israel to withdraw from Lebanon.
�� Resolution 501: calls on Israel to stop attacks against Lebanon and withdraw its
�� troops.
�� Resolution 509: demands that Israel withdraw its forces forthwith and unconditionally
�� from Lebanon.
�� Resolution 515: demands that Israel lift its siege of Beirut and allow food supplies to
�� be brought in.
�� Resolution 517: censures Israel for failing to obey UN resolutions and demands that
�� Israel withdraw its forces from Lebanon.
�� Resolution 518: demands that Israel cooperate fully with UN forces in Lebanon.
�� Resolution 520: condemns Israel's attack into West Beirut.
�� Resolution 573: condemns Israel vigorously for bombing Tunisia in attack on PLO
�� headquarters.
�� Resolution 587: takes note of previous calls on Israel to withdraw its forces from
�� Lebanon and urges all parties to withdraw.
�� Resolution 592: strongly deplores the killing of Palestinian students at Bir Zeit
�� University by Israeli troops.
�� Resolution 605: strongly deplores Israel's policies and practices denying the human
�� rights of Palestinians.
�� Resolution 607: calls on Israel not to deport Palestinians and strongly requests it to
�� abide by the Fourth Geneva Convention.
�� Resolution 608: deeply regrets that Israel has defied the United Nations and deported
�� Palestinian civilians.
�� Resolution 636: deeply regrets Israeli deportation of Palestinian civilians.
�� Resolution 641: deplores Israel's continuing deportation of Palestinians.
�� Resolution 672: condemns Israel for violence against Palestinians at the Haram
�� Al‑Sharif/Temple Mount.
�� Resolution 673: deplores Israel's refusal to cooperate with the United Nations.
�� Resolution 681: deplores Israel's resumption of the deportation of Palestinians.
�� Resolution 694: deplores Israel's deportation of Palestinians and calls on it to ensure
�� their safe and immediate return.
�� Resolution 726: strongly condemns Israel's deportation of Palestinians.
�� Resolution 799: strongly condemns Israel's deportation of 413 Palestinians and calls
�� for their immediate return.
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
Subject:
������� Comparing UN resolutions for Iraq and Israel
�� Date:
������� Tue, 11 Feb 2003 15:33:53 ‑0800
�� From:
������� Meggie <[email protected]>
���� To:
������� Willie Martin <[email protected]>
������������������� �
������������������������������ Comparing Violations of UN Resolutions by Iraq and Israel
���� Al‑Jazeerah Arabic
�������� ???????
����� Arab Cartoonists
�������� Articles
������� Columnists
������� Contact us
������� Documents
���� ���Editorials
�������� Essays
�� Human Price of the Israeli
��� Occupation of Palestine
��������� Islam
���� letters to the editor
������ Media Watch
��� Mission and meaning of
������ Al‑Jazeerah
������ News Photos
����� News Archives
���� Opinion Editorials
�������� Poetry
����� Women in News
������������������������������������������������ By Richard B. Du Boff
������������������������������������������������ [email protected]
������������������������������ ������������������������9/23/02
���������������������� IRAQ:
���������������������� UN Resolutions violated, ignored: 16
���������������������� Countries attacked, invaded, violated: Iran, Kuwait
���������������������� Countries occupied for years: NONE >Countries currently occupying: NONE
���������������������� Territory illegally annexed: NONE >Wars started: 1980, 1990
���������������������� Possesses weapons of mass destruction: To be determined
���������������������� Possesses nuclear weapons: No
���������������������� Most notable atrocity against civilians: 5,000 Kurdish civilians were killed in the village of
���������������������� Halabja, March 1988
���������������������� Currently under a regime of UN sanctions: Yes
������������������� ���ISRAEL:
���������������������� UN Resolutions violated, ignored: 68
���������������������� Countries attacked, invaded, violated: Egypt, Jordan, Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, Tunisia
���������������������� Countries occupied for years: Egypt, Lebanon, Syria
���������������������� Countries currently occupying: Syria Territory illegally annexed: Golan Heights, Jerusalem,
���������������������� Palestinian Territories
���������������������� Wars started: 1956, 1967, 1982
���������������������� Possesses weapons of mass destruction: Yes
���������������������� Possesses nuclear weapons: Yes
���������������������� Most notable atrocity against civilians: 17,500 Lebanese civilians killed in 1982 invasion of
���������������������� Lebanon
������������� ���������Currently under a regime of UN sanctions: No
�����������������������
���������������������� UN Resolutions pertaining to Iraq: (16)
���������������������� UNSCR 678 ‑ November 29, 1990, UNSCR 686 ‑ March 2, 1991, UNSCR 687 ‑ April
���������� ������������3, 1991, UNSCR 688 ‑ April 5, 1991, UNSCR 707 ‑ August 15, 1991, UNSCR 715 ‑
���������������������� October 11, 1991, UNSCR 949 ‑ October 15, 1994, UNSCR 1051 ‑ March 27, 1996,
���������������������� UNSCR 1060 ‑ June 12, 1996, UNSCR 1115 ‑ June 21, 1997, UNSCR 1134 ‑ October
���������������������� 23, 1997, UNSCR 1137 ‑ November 12, 1997, UNSCR 1154 ‑ March 2, 1998,
���������������������� UNSCR 1194 ‑ September 9, 1998, UNSCR 1205 ‑ November 5, 1998, UNSCR 1284
���������������������� ‑ December 17, 1999.
���������������������� UN Resolutions pertaining to Israel: (68)
���������������������� UNSCR 42 (1948) of 5 March 1948 [Adopted at 263rd meeting (8‑0‑3) (3 abstentions
���������������������� were Argentina, Syria, United Kingdom)]
��������� �������������UNSCR 43 (1948) of 1 April 1948 [Adopted at 277th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 44 (1948) of 1 April 1948 [Adopted at 277th meeting (9‑0‑2) (2 abstentions
���������������������� were Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic, U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 46 (1948) of 17 April 1948 [Adopted at 283rd meeting (9‑0‑2) (2 abstentions
���������������������� were Ukrainian S.S.R., U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 48 (1948) of 23 April 1948 [Adopted at 287th meeting (8‑0‑3) (3 abstentions
���������������������� were Colombia, Ukrainian S.S.R., U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 49 (1948) of 22 May 1948 [Adopted at 302nd meeting (8‑0‑3) (3 abstentions
���������������������� were Syria, Ukrainian S.S.R., U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 50 (1948) of 29 May 1948 [Adopted at 310th meeting (Draft was voted on in
���������������������� parts, no vote taken on text as a whole.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 53 (1948) of 7 July 1948 [Adopted at 331st meeting (8‑0‑3) (3 >abstentions
���������������������� were Syria, Ukrainian S.S.R., U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 54 (1948) of 15 July 1948 [Adopted at 338th meeting (7‑1‑3) (1 against was
���������������������� Syria, 3 abstentions were Argentina, Ukrainian S.S.R., U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 56 (1948) of 19 August 1948 [Adopted at 354th meeting (Draft was voted on in
���������������������� parts, no vote taken on the text as a whole.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 57 (1948) of 18 September 1948 [Adopted at 358th meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 59 (1948) of 19 October 1948 [Adopted at 367th meeting ‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 60 (1948) of 29 October 1948 [Adopted at 375th meeting (without a vote)]
���������������������� UNSCR 61 (1948) of 4 November 1948 [Adopted at 377th meeting (9‑1‑1) (1 against
���������������������� was Ukrainian S.S.R.; 1 abstention was U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 62 (1948) of 16 November 1948 [Adopted at 381st meeting (Draft was voted on
���������������������� in parts, no vote taken on the text as a whole.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 66 (1948) of 29 December 1948 [Adopted at 396th meeting (8‑0‑3) (3
���������������������� abstentions were Ukrainian S.S.R., U.S.S.R., U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 69 (1949) of 4 March 1949 [Adopted at 414th meeting (9‑1‑1) (1 against was
���������������������� Egypt, 1 abstention was U.K.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 72 (1949) of 11 August 1949 [Adopted at 437th meeting (without vote)]
���������������������� UNSCR 73 (1949) of 11 August 1949 [Adopted at 437th meeting (9‑0‑2) (2 abstentions
���������������������� were Ukrainian S.S.R., U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 101 (1953) of 24 November 1953 [Adopted at 642nd meeting (9‑0‑2) (2
���������������������� abstentions were Lebanon, U.S.S.R.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 89 (1950) of 17 November 1950 [Adopted at 524th meeting (10‑0‑2) (2
���������������������� abstentions were Egypt, U.S.S.R.)]
����� �����������������UNSCR 119 (1956) of 31 October 1956 [Adopted at 751st meeting (7‑2‑2) (2 against
���������������������� were France, U.K., 2 abstentions were Australia, Belgium)]
���������������������� UNSCR 127 (1958) of 22 January 1958 [Adopted at 810th meeting � unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 162 (1961) of 11 April 1961 [Adopted at 949th meeting (8‑0‑3) (3 abstentions
���������������������� were Ceylon, U.S.S.R., United Arab Republic)
���������������������� UNSCR 228 (1966) of 25 November 1966 [Adopted at 1328th meeting (14‑01) (1
���������������������� abstention was New Zealand)]
���������������������� UNSCR 233 (1967) of 6 June 1967 [Adopted at 1348th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 234 (1967) of 7 June 1967 [Adopted at 1350th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 237 (1967) of 14 June 1967 [Adopted at 1361st meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 242 (1967) of 22 November 1967 [Adopted 1382nd meeting ‑unanimously]
�������������� ��������UNSCR 248 (1968) of 24 March 1968 [Adopted at 1407th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 250 (1968) of 27 April 1968 [Adopted at 1417th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR No. 251 (1968) of 2 May 1968 [Adopted at 1420th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR No. 252 (1968) of 21 May 1968 [Adopted at 1426th meeting (13‑0‑2) (2
���������������������� abstentions were Canada, U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 259 (1968) of 27 September 1968 [Adopted at 1454th meeting (12‑0‑3) (3
���������������������� abstentions were Canada, Denmark, U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 267 (1969) of 3 July 1969 [Adopted at 1485th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 271 (1969) of 15 September 1969 [Adopted at 1512th meeting (11‑0‑4) (4
���������������������� abstentions were Colombia, Finland, Paraguay, U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 298 (1971) of 25 September 1971 [Adopted at 1582nd meeting (14‑0‑1)(1
���������������������� abstention was Syria)]
���������������������� UNSCR 331 (1973) of 20 April 1973 [Adopted at 1710th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 338 (1973) of 22 October 1973 [Adopted at 1747th meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 339 (1973) of 23 October 1973 [Adopted at 1748th meeting (14‑0‑0) (China
���������������������� did not vote)]
���������������������� UNSCR 344 (1973) of 15 December 1973 [Adopted at 1760th meeting (10‑0‑4) (4
���������������������� abstentions were France, U.S.S.R., U.K., U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 381 (1975) of 30 November 1975 [Adopted at 1856th meeting (13‑0‑0) (China
���������������������� and Iraq did not vote)]
���������������������� UNSCR 425 (1978) of 19 March 1978 [Adopted at 2074th meeting (12‑0‑2) (2
���������������������� abstentions were Czechoslovakia and U.S.S.R., China did not participate in the voting)]
���������������������� UNSCR 446 (1979) of 22 March 1979 [Adopted at 2134th meeting (12‑0‑3) (3
���������������������� abstentions were Norway, U.K., U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 452 (1979) of 20 July 1979 [Adopted at 2159th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1 abstention
���������������������� was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 465 (1980) of 1 March 1980 [Adopted at 2203rd meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 468 (1980) of 8 May 1980 [Adopted at 2221st meeting (14‑0‑1) (1 abstention
���������������������� was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 469 (1980) of 20 May 1980 [Adopted at 2223rd meeting (14‑0‑1) (1 abstention
�� ��������������������was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 471 (1980) of 5 June 1980 [Adopted at 2226th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1 abstention
���������������������� was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 476 (1980) of 30 June 1980 [Adopted at 2242nd meeting (14‑0‑1) (1 abstention
���������������������� was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 478 (1980) of 20 August 1980 [Adopted at 2245th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� >abstention was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 484 (1980) of 19 December 1980 [Adopted 2260th meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 500 (1982) of 28 January 1982 [Adopted at 2330th meeting (13‑0‑2) (2
���������������������� abstentions were U.K., U.S.)] UNSCR 508 (1982) of 5 June 1982 [Adopted at 2374th
����� �����������������meeting �unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 509 (1982) of 6 June 1982 [Adopted at 2375th meeting � unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 512 (1982) of 19 June 1982 [Adopted at 2380th meeting � unanimously]
��������������� �������UNSCR 513 (1982) of 4 July 1982 [Adopted at 2382nd meeting � unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 515 (1982) of 29 July 1982 [Adopted at 2385th meeting (14‑0‑0) (U.S. did not
���������������������� vote)
���������������������� UNSCR 516 (1982) of 1 August 1982 [Adopted at 2386th meeting � unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 517 (1982) of 4 August 1982 [Adopted at 2389th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� abstention was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 518 (1982) of 12 August 1982 [Adopted at 2392nd meeting � unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 520 (1982) of 17 September 1982 [Adopted at 2395th meeting � >unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 521 (1982) of 19 September 1982 [Adopted 2396th meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 573 (1985) of 4 October 1985 [Adopted at 2615th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� abstention was U.S.)
���������������������� UNSCR 592 (1986) of 8 December 1986 [Adopted at 2727th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������� ������������>abstention was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 605 (1987) of 22 December 1987 [Adopted at 2777th meeting (14‑0‑1) >(1
���������������������� abstention was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 607 (1988) of 5 January 1988 [Adopted at 2780th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 608 (1988) of 14 January 1988 [Adopted at 2781st meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� abstention was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 611 (1988) of 25 April 1988 [Adopted at 2810th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1 abstention
���������������������� was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 636 (1989) of 6 July 1989 [Adopted at 2870th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1 abstention
���������������������� was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 641 (1989) of 30 August 1989 [Adopted at 2883rd meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� abstention was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 672 (1990) of 12 October 1990 [Adopted at 2948th meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 673 (1990) of 24 October 1990 [Adopted at 2949th meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 681 (1990) of 20 December 1990 [Adopted at 2970th meeting ‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 694 (1991) of 24 May 1991 [Adopted at 2989th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������� ������UNSCR 726 (1992) of 6 January 1992 [Adopted at 3026th meeting ‑ unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 799 (1992) of 18 December 1992 [Adopted at 3151st meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 904 (1994) of 18 March 1994 [Adopted at 3351st meeting � unanimously (Draft
���������������������� was voted on in parts, with the U.S. abstaining on two preambular paragraphs. No vote
���������������������� was taken on the text as a whole.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 1073 (1996) of 28 September 1996 [Adopted at 3698th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� abstention was U.S.)]
���������������������� UNSCR 1322 (2000) of 7 October 2000 Adopted at 4205th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� abstention was U.S.)]
������������� ���������UNSCR 1397 (2002) of 12 March 2002 [Adopted at 4304th meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
���������������������� abstention was the Syrian Arab Republic)]
���������������������� UNSCR 1402 (2002) of 30 March 2002 [Adopted at 4503 rd meeting (14‑0‑1) (1
������� ���������������abstention was the Syrian Arab Republic)]
���������������������� UNSCR 1403 (2002) of 4 April 2002 [Adopted at 4506 th meeting‑unanimously]
���������������������� UNSCR 1405 (2002) of 19 April 2002 [Adopted at 4516th meeting‑unanimously]
������������������������
������������������������ Opinions expressed in various sections are the sole responsibility of their authors and they may not
������������������������������������������������� represent Al‑Jazeerah's.